Cost Comparison: Composite Decking vs. Wood Decking

When it comes to building or replacing a deck, one of the biggest decisions homeowners face is choosing the right material. The most common options are composite decking and traditional wood decking. Each material has its own set of benefits and drawbacks, and understanding the cost implications can help you make an informed decision. In this article, we’ll break down the initial costs, long-term savings, maintenance costs, and value addition to your property when comparing composite decking with wood decking.

Let’s weigh the pros and cons  ​

1. Initial Costs vs. Long-Term Savings 
Composite Decking: 
Composite decking is generally more expensive upfront than wood decking. The initial cost per square foot can be significantly higher, primarily due to the advanced manufacturing process that combines wood fibers and recycled plastics to create a durable, weather-resistant product.  
  
-Initial Cost: Composite decking typically costs between $30 and $45 per square foot, including materials and installation. Higher-end options can exceed $50 per square foot.  
  
- Long-Term Savings: While the initial investment is higher, composite decking pays off over time. Its durability, resistance to rot, insects, and fading mean that you’ll spend far less on repairs and replacements compared to wood decking. Additionally, composite decks often come with long warranties, some up to 25 years, providing peace of mind and reducing future costs. 
  
Wood Decking: 
Wood decking, especially when using pressure-treated lumber or more affordable softwoods like pine, has a lower upfront cost. This makes it an attractive option for budget-conscious homeowners. 
  
- Initial Cost: Wood decking generally costs between $15 and $25 per square foot, including materials and installation. Exotic hardwoods, like Ipe or Teak, can cost upwards of $35 per square foot, but pressure-treated pine and cedar are much less expensive. 
  
- Long-Term Savings: Although wood decking has a lower initial cost, it requires more maintenance over its lifespan. This can lead to higher long-term expenses due to the need for regular staining, sealing, and possible repairs or replacements due to rot or insect damage. Over time, these costs can add up, making wood decking potentially more expensive than composite decking in the long run. 
  
2. Maintenance Costs Over the Lifespan of the Deck 
Composite Decking: 
One of the most significant advantages of composite decking is its low maintenance requirements. Unlike wood, composite decking doesn’t need to be stained, sealed, or painted. It’s designed to withstand the elements without deteriorating, which means you’ll spend less time and money on upkeep. 
  
- Maintenance Costs: Composite decks require minimal maintenance, typically only needing an occasional cleaning with soap and water. Over the lifespan of the deck, you can expect to spend significantly less on maintenance compared to wood decking. The absence of ongoing maintenance costs contributes to the long-term savings that make composite decking a cost-effective choice. 
  
Wood Decking: 
Wood decking is beautiful and natural, but it requires regular maintenance to keep it looking its best and to extend its lifespan. This includes annual cleaning, staining, and sealing to protect against moisture, UV rays, and insects. 
  
- Maintenance Costs: The cost of maintaining a wood deck can add up over time. Staining and sealing alone can cost several hundred dollars each year, depending on the size of the deck and the products used. Additionally, wood decking is more susceptible to rot, warping, and insect damage, which may result in costly repairs or even full deck replacement sooner than with composite decking. 
  
3. Value Addition to the Property 
  
Composite Decking: 
Investing in composite decking can be a smart move if you’re looking to add long-term value to your property. Potential homebuyers often appreciate the durability, low maintenance, and modern appearance of composite decks, which can make your home more attractive on the market. 
  
- Value Addition: Composite decking is seen as a premium product that can enhance the overall value of your property. Its longevity and low maintenance appeal to buyers who are looking for a hassle-free outdoor living space. The higher initial cost of composite decking can be offset by the added resale value of your home, making it a wise investment for the future. 
  
Wood Decking: 
Wood decking, with its classic appeal and natural beauty, also adds value to a property. However, its higher maintenance requirements and potential for quicker wear and tear may not be as appealing to all buyers. 
  
- Value Addition: While wood decking does add value to a home, the ongoing maintenance and potential for issues like rot or insect damage may deter some buyers. If you’re planning to sell your home, prospective buyers may factor in the cost and effort of maintaining a wood deck when making their decision, which could affect the overall perceived value. 
  
When deciding between composite decking and wood decking, it’s important to consider not only the initial cost but also the long-term savings, maintenance requirements, and the potential value addition to your property.  
  
Conclusion 
- Composite Decking: Although it comes with a higher upfront cost, composite decking offers significant long-term savings due to its low maintenance and durability. It’s a smart choice for homeowners looking for a beautiful, low-maintenance deck that will stand the test of time and add value to their home. 
  
- Wood Decking: Wood decking offers a more affordable initial investment and the timeless beauty of natural wood. However, the ongoing maintenance and potential for repairs should be factored into your decision. For those who enjoy the look and feel of wood and don’t mind the upkeep, wood decking remains a viable option. 
  
Ultimately, the right choice for your decking needs will depend on your budget, lifestyle, and long-term goals for your home. Whether you choose composite or wood, a well-maintained deck is a valuable addition to any home, providing years of enjoyment and enhancing your outdoor living space. Contact us today if you're ready to get started.